How not to Win Friends and Influence People
Posted by BKisida | Education, Fayetteville, AR, Politics | February 10, 2010
On Monday, the Northwest Arkansas Times ran an op-ed from a local tea-partyer, James Laubler, that went on at length about the Fayetteville School Board’s plan to use a combination of reallocation and refinancing to pay for improvements to the current high school.
Laubler made a couple of reasonable points. It is reasonable to wonder if the Board can make good on their promise of budget cuts (which have yet to be spelled out) and whether or not expected future revenues will hold true. But it isn’t accurate to say that the board has decided to “circumvent the voters.” The Board has a budget that they are free to work with, and they are free to allocate the approved budget as they see fit. Unlike the situation with the proposed millage that was defeated, the overall size of the district’s budget is not being grown under the current plan. If anything, the Board should be commended for coming up with a fiscally responsible way to improve the current high school.
Laubler even seems to take issue with the very idea that the federal government is subsidizing the rate at which the district will have to pay back any stimulus money it receives, but one can hardly blame the Board for making sure that Fayetteville takes advantage of what’s being offered. If Laubler has an issue with the provisions of the stimulus money, then he should take that up with federal lawmakers. From our local perspective, it would be ridiculous to not take advantage of the opportunity.
The real problem with Lauber’s rant, though, was that his arguments dissolved into outlandish melodrama. He said the Board must be “socialists, communists, or bought politicians with no moral compass,” and he reminds us all that “this is not a socialist or communist nation.” He says there is a movement in this country to take back “our country from these types,” followed up with threatening language that he “wouldn’t want to be the one to ultimately challenge these patriots.” He closes with more threatening innuendo, as he references the American Revolution and tells the Board not to “anger us the way the last king did.”
Ugh.
Ultimately, and with sweet irony, the tactics employed by those who rely on this type of grandstanding are the architects of their own undoing. While there are some segments of our population who may be moved by such demagoguery, most Americans prefer common sense and reasonable discussion. They respect the opinions of reasonable people, and reject those who aren’t.
If anything, Lauber’s letter assured sensible Fayettevillians that the Board’s plans are sensible. There’s not many who want to be on the side of the local McCarthyite.
Apparently, political ineptitude runs throughout the “tea party” movement. Recent events at their national convention were downright embarrassing.
| The Daily Show With Jon Stewart | Mon – Thurs 11p / 10c | |||
| AmeriGasm | ||||
|
||||

Great work Brian. Our school leaders have done a good job moving forward from the failed millage election. I don’t believe any thinking-person could be convinced otherwise by Mr. Laubler’s ridiculous screed.
These teapartyers remind me more of a 4yr old who is scared of imaginary monsters in the closet than McCarthyites. McCarthy was smart and truly sinister. He deftly manipulated public fear for power. While the teapartyers are using fear to garner power, I have not seen any evidence that their leaders are very smart or have any real political strategy. Sarah Palin, really!!
Don’t forget, they also had Tim Tancredo speak at their convention. Betweeen him and Palin, I’m not sure who is more of a punchline.
But I don’t want to completely throw Laubler in with that lot. He clearly cares about the community and the country, and I think if he adopted a different tone he might be more effective in convincing others that he has reasonable concerns.