Is Philadelphia Stealer Just a Scam Artist?

Posted by BKisida | Uncategorized | July 15, 2010

9 Comments

I spit my mouthful of iced-tea halfway across the room today (figuratively) when I heard that Fayetteville Mayor Lioneld Jordan wanted to give $19,000 to Terry Bradshaw and a fake news outlet so they would produce a fake news segment promoting Fayetteville.  Here’s a link to the Northwest Arkansas Times story.  Here’s an excerpt:

“Fayetteville could gain national exposure when a production crew for the show “Today In America” arrives to showcase the area’s economic development possibilities and the good qualities of living here.

But it also comes with a price tag of more than $19,000.

“Today in America” is a nationally broadcast cable program moderated by NFL icon Terry Bradshaw. It features inspirational stories from across the country centering on a range of topics such as travel and lifestyle, business or medicine.

The Fayetteville spot will be about five minutes long and will include interviews with Fayetteville leaders, according to a memo Smith sent to the City Council. The project is not a typical news feature. Instead, it’s a collaborative project between the city and “Today In America.” The city will assist in script-writing by filling out a questionnaire, and gets final edit approval, according the participation agreement document.

In the case of the local segment, the producers contacted Fayetteville officials several weeks ago to inquire about shooting the piece, said Mayor Lioneld Jordan. The production company took interest in the Fayetteville Forward economic development initiative Jordan used to ask residents what sort of community they wanted Fayetteville to be.

Lindsley Smith, the city’s communication director, said the show’s producers are also interested in taking a closer look at what contributes to what many see as Fayetteville’s high quality of life. The segment will highlight why Fayetteville is a top environment for business.

“We really want to highlight the city, and I think this will put us on the national scene,” said Jordan.”

According to the city’s agreement with “Today in America,” Fayetteville will pay $19,800 for production. The money will come from the city’s economic development fund, Jordan said.”

Is it a scam? A lot of people certainly think so.  Read for yourself.  Here’s an article from CBS Moneywatch.  Here’s an article from ripoffreport.com.  Here’s a forum of others discussing that they think it is a scam.  And apparently, the group Bradshaw is with isn’t the only outfit soliciting anyone and everyone to pay for a fake news story to promote themselves.  There’s a little industry of these players.

Of course, one might argue that if  “Today in America” actually buys some time at 3 a.m. on some lame cable channel and mentions Fayetteville a few times, then the 19k is well-spent.  Scam or no scam, our name would get out there.

Then again, is that really the demographic we should be going for?  Folks watching fake-news infomercials at 3 a.m.?  I’d rather send the money to this guy.  He says he can guarantee prosperity.

UPDATE: The Fayetteville City Council approved the infomercial.  I have a new post about this topic here.
_

Riff Sharing:
  • Print
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Twitter
  • RSS
  • email

Comments (9)

[...] Over at Mid-Riffs, the question is raised as to whether should get in bed with “Today in America” paying $19,800 to finance a five-minute staged “news” segment about the city and its Fayetteville Forward initiative. [...]

This Robert Tilton guy makes a lot of sense! Where do I send the checks?

I fear that Lioneld Jordon is becoming another Dan Coody – all promotion and no economic plan.

The $19K could be better spent elsewhere.

[...] – On Tuesday, the Fayetteville City Council approved spending nearly $20,000 dollars to buy paid infomercial time on the infomerical show “Today in America.” See the Fayetteville Flyer coverage here.  See my previous post where I raised questions that this show contacting us was nothing more than a scam here.  [...]

I am the VP of Production for Today in America and welcome any and all visitors from Fayettville to tour our studios. We are pleased to be working with the city and believe the segment will be well received. For those of you that understand a little bit about media, we are a real show that airs at good hours throughout the day. We do not air at 3 AM as this individual would have you believe. We are very excited about working with the city, but it is a shame that someone would sabotage those positive efforts by falsely accusing our company of being a scam. Again, we look forward to working with all of you, and no we are not a scam.

Jim

Hey Jim, thanks for stopping by. Since I assume you aren’t a regular reader of this blog, I’m guessing that someone in city administration alerted you to this post. Glad to know they’re stopping by too.

I didn’t say your business was a scam, but I did cite and link to some others who make that claim. And, yes, I am quite skeptical about the manner in which you solicited our city. The report from CBS MoneyWatch, and the other reports I mentioned, all had one element in common. They all reported that Today In America broadly solicits potential advertisers and does not truly have any specific interest in who they contact. This is of course perfectly legal, but somewhat disingenuous when our local media is repeating claims from city officials that Today In America sees Fayetteville as something more than a paying customer.

And, as I indicated in my post, you may very well produce a good product and it may very well be a good thing for the city to spend money on. But the way that this has played out so far has me doubting your sincerity, and as result, I am doubting the quality of the end product.

Your comment is, unfortunately, more of the same. You said this:

“For those of you that understand a little bit about media, we are a real show that airs at good hours throughout the day.”

Actually Jim, I understand a lot about media. I know enough to know that paid promotional spots are not “real shows.” And when you claim they are, you’re essentially begging me to refer to you as a scam. Stop trying to pretend you’re something that you’re not, and maybe then we can have a valid conversation about the merits of your infomercial program.

And while you’re here, so there’s no more confusion, why don’t you let us all know precisely what time of day and on what channel your last national broadcast was.

[...] plans to pay the promotional group for airtime.  What he said and my response are here. Riff [...]

Yo, Jim. We spell it Fayetteville not Fayettville.

BKisida, if you go to Today in America’s website http://www.watchtia.com/airings/ you’ll see all their national airings scheduled.

Don’t worry, it won’t take long since it is totally blank.