It’s Heretical to Ask …. but Should We Watch Football?
Posted by GRitter | Arkansas, Music - Movies - Entertainment | October 19, 2010
For many of us in Arkansas, our exciting fall football Saturday afternoon was interrupted by Nick Fairlie when he horse-collared Arkansas QB Ryan Mallett in the second quarter. Perhaps most fans were able to forget about this when backup QB Tyler Wilson came in and threw for about 500 yards until things unraveled thanks to the refs and mistakes late in the second half. (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ozJajhXSTJE)
In case we Arkansas football fans were able to overlook Mallett’s head injury while we focused on curious referee decisions on Saturday, we were reminded on Sunday about the violence of this game many of us love to play, watch, and support. Violent hits to the head were delivered, and concussions visited upon, so many players that it is hard to count. But, just for fun, I’ll list the few I can remember — Todd Heap of the Baltimore Ravens, Josh Cribbs and Mohamed Massaquoi of the Cleveland Browns (both by James Harrison, who likes to “hurt, but not injure” his opponents), and DeSean Jackson of the Philadelphia Eagles. The Jackson hit was, by far, the most painful. Take a look, but be warned that it is difficult to watch:
What’s worse, this horrific news and video came out of another college game this weekend, but it may have gone under the radar for many since the game did not involve major football powerhouses:
“Rutgers defensive tackle Eric LeGrand is paralyzed from the neck down after being injured in a game this weekend, team officials said Sunday. Rutgers Coach Greg Schiano said LeGrand suffered a spinal cord injury in Saturday’s game against Army when he made a tackle on a kickoff return with 5:10 to play in the game. The junior underwent emergency surgery at Hackensack University Medical Center to stabilize his spine but has no movement below his neck. He will remain at the hospital indefinitely”
****
I realize that these young men and adults make an active choice to play this game, just like boxers make the choice to engage in sport that may well cause severe injury. However, it does make me think of the stories of Roman Gladiator matches, in which the gladiators (some willing volunteers and some not), according to Wikipedia, “entertained audiences in the Roman Republic and Roman Empire in violent confrontations with other gladiators”. In our large modern “Colosseums”, our football gladiators engage in thrilling (but sometimes dangerous) sport for their own enjoyment and we all benefit as spectators.
Is this OK? Perhaps society, as a whole, has decided that the collective positives of the game (excitement, physical training, discipline-buidling, camaraderie, and the potential for riches for players; excitement, fun, and community building for the spectators) may exceed the collective negatives (glorification of violence for all of us and the possibility of severe injuries for the players) of the game … Or … perhaps we choose to blissfully ignore the negatives so that we can continue to enjoy our tailgating, partying, and even community-building on football Saturdays and Sundays during the beautiful Autumn weekends.
Then, again, I may be irrationally thinking about the true danger of the sport after a particularly violent football weekend that is not representative of the actual risks facing players on a week by week basis. And I may simply be noticing these injuries more as my young children get older and closer to the age of the Rutgers football player who ran into the football stadium on Saturday, was carted out, and may never, ever, walk again.
In the end, I am not sure what to do with these thoughts? Might we all be better off with less football? And, if so, can we perhaps wait until next week to kick our football habit so that we get to shower Houston Nutt with boos when he re-enters Fayetteville on Saturday morning??



Donald Harington died over the weekend. Harington was an amazing novelist and a professor of art at the University of Arkansas. He was also a really cool guy, as many of his students at the U of A will attest to. If I had to recommend one of his books to those unfamiliar with his work, I’d urge you to start with The Architecture of the Arkansas Ozarks. You won’t be disappointed.



